really good graphics, good gameplay but nothing new on it

sorry, no constructive criticism, it's just not my cup of tea. oh actually, the tutorial maybe gives too much in one go, might split it up a bit, make 2 or 3 intro levels where the player is eased into the system.

Very polished. I like. Haven't delved into the game too much yet, but from what I can tell, the cake system looks unique.

It's a beautiful creation, I really appreciate the graphics, the music, and all the things that I can do in the game. The only problem I see is : What is the difference between your game and this one : http://novelconcepts.co.uk/FlashElementTD/ or any tower defence? Well you could say that the theme used is different, the enemies are not the same, and that the graphics used for everything are different, but it remains very similar to other tower defence games.

In general the game proposed here is really impressive, as I programmer myself I am really impressed by the game.

But what the game proposes to the player is the same thing as the other tower defence games seen online. As a game designer, I am not impressed. It seems cruel to say, I know all the work that the game represents. But games are about interactions. Cake Pirate is fun that is for sure, but all the other tower defence games that have I played were fun too and very similar.

In other words, I don't want to change what the game is, it is a really great game. But could it be the next Braid? I don't think so... In my opinion it is a well made game and it is fun, I just personally find it unoriginal. I hope the creator is going to put the same amount of effort into an original game with original game mechanics

Hmm. The title music is from Super Mario RPG. This looks beautiful to me, but I'm not the biggest tower defense fan. The concept looks pretty unique to me too.

The system seems a little complicated at first, but I think the concept brings something fresh and new to the tower defense genre. I like the visual style too, nice and cheerful.