the graphics and ambiance of this game are great and remind me of the old PS2 game Dark Cloud 2. Other than that the actual gameplay and integrate structure of the game was terrible. you didn't even make it a point to have doing something good in the game be distinguished from something bad. That and it's just not interesting at all. I think it's too serious of a tone for what it is- perfume. Animations would help you tremendously i think.

Now that i think about it more 1 is a bit too harsh, so know that I'd give it a 2 if given a do over. A two may sound douchey as well, but it is only because i see this as an unfinished piece. I see the potential and you (and team) clearly have the talent.

-the best of luck for future titles :)